Sofa conundrum

I didn't realize that our trip home this past Christmas would result in the furniture bonanza that it turned into. During summer break, I spent quite a bit of time looking at furniture with my cousin. My plan was to find my furniture style before Joern confused me. In a lot of ways, it was useful. Yet, I totally caved when it came to our sofa.
We ended up purchasing the following sectional for our living room:
the CU2 sectional from Bassett Furniture.

While I do love it, now that I've had a bit of down-time, I realized this may not be the absolute best sofa for our living room. I'm not 100% happy with the color, and I do worry that the sofa may be a bit too soft for my back. Plus, I'm not sure it entirely goes with the general feel of the rest of the main floor.

Our kitchen will most likely have a very classical feel, like this:


Our dining room inspiration board is a few posts below. I have a feeling our dining room will have a pretty formal look, no matter what chairs we purchase. The table is so beautiful, there is little chance to give it an informal look.

That being said, I really feel like a chaise sectional, that is like a camel wide-wale corduroy, to me just doesn't fit. I know that the whole thing doesn't have to go or match, but I think that the current sofa would be better in our cellar in our entertainment room.

So, here are my current ideas:
Brynn Sectional (click on link, then imagine this as a sectional in brown leather)
I absolutely love this sectional, in a chocolate leather of course. I adore the
tufting.
Or,

Fremont sectional from Bassett Furniture.
I'm waiting for a price on this sofa, with nailhead trim. I've emailed our designer at Bassett in Milford.
And then, Joern loves this:

The Mercer sectional, also from Bassett Furniture.

I'm kind-of hoping for the deal of the century on the second choice, the Fremont sectional. The designer we have worked with is wonderful, and I am so very happy with Bassett. They are really willing to work with us, with our strange time-frame and our odd problem of needing to order via email. I'm not sure Macy's will be so easy to work with. Of course, I do absolutely love the sectional from Macy's though. I like Joern's choice, the Mercer sectional, but it seems a little modern to me. I'm not a modern girl. Obviously, we are still in the talking stage.

So, here is where I open my blog up for opinions. Really. Anybody? Thoughts???
Thanks!